Teachers often ask, “What’s the difference between (the textbook I’m using now) and Singapore Math textbooks?” While there are many answers, I’d like to direct you to a resource that has been pointing out some differences for over a year.
Once a week, Lefty (as in left-brained) over at Out In Left Field posts assignment comparisons between either a traditional math program or Singapore Math and various reform math textbooks.
From the original post:
Math problems of the week: Reform Math vs. other math
We’ll pair up a specific assignment drawn from this set with a specific assignment drawn either from a traditional series like McGraw-Hill, or from the foreign series most popular in America: Singapore Math
I’ll try to pick assignments that take place at approximately the same point in the school year. For example, I might choose two assignments from the first few weeks of first grade, or from the last few weeks of second grade, or from approximately 2/3 of the way into third grade.
At the end of many posts are some thought provoking Extra Credit questions. Some examples:
- Which problem set involves more rote repetition of a given algorithm?
- Which problem set is more accessible to children with language impairments?
- Discuss how the two problem sets reflect the cultural and political differences between American and Singaporean societies.
Although many of the sample problems come from Singapore Math, there are also comparisons to traditional math books from the 1920s.
Earlier this month, I posted the following problem from a Nanyang Primary School 2007 Preliminary Examination I found at MissKoh.com:
A mixture, weighing 100 kg is made up of 2 chemicals A and B in the ratio of 7:3. When some volume of Chemical A evaporates, the content of Chemical A is reduced to 60% of the new mixture. What is the mass of the mixture now?
I thought I’d share how my son worked the problem:
He knew that if he multiplied 40% x 2.5, he’d get 100% so:
2.5 x 30 kg = 2.5 x 40%
75kg = 100%
I used a different drawing for “after” :
How did you solve the problem?
An interesting word problem was recently posted at the SingaporeMath Yahoo group. The original poster wrote for help solving it without algebra and mentioned that it was from the Primary 4 books. This seems a little advanced compared to the problems in the text and workbooks. I believe the problem could be from the Challenging Word problems series, which provides answers only.
There are 285 teachers and students in the hall. 5/6 of the students and 1/3 of the teachers went out of the hall. There is an equal number of students and teachers left in the hall. How many teachers were there in the hall at first?
If 5/6 of the students and 1/3 of the teachers went out, there would be 1/6 of the students and 2/3 of the teachers left in the hall.
Begin with the end result:
2/3 of the amount of teachers is equal to 1/6 of the amount of students. For every unit of students, there are 2 units of teachers.
Then let’s work back to how many there were at first:
There are 285 people divided into 15 units.
285 ÷ 15 = 19 people per unit.
There were 3 units of 19, or 57 teachers in the hall at first.
Then, to check out work, let’s find out how many students there were at first.
12 units x 19 people in each = 228 students
228 students + 57 teachers = 285 teachers and students were in the hall at first.
How can you extend the problem?